Why AT&T's deal for T-Mobile would never have worked

A. Michael Noll

A. Michael Noll

Back in 2000, Deutsche Telekom (XETRA: DTE.DE) initiated its acquisition of VoiceStream Wireless for $50.5 billion. I wrote then in the Los Angeles Times that "this deal makes no sense financially" ("A Big 'Nein' to Deutsche Telekom," July 26, 2000, p. B9). I also opposed the acquisition since the German government owned much of Deutsche Telekom's stock.

But the acquisition went through--and Deutsche Telekom later regretted its overpaid purchase, even after renaming it T-Mobile.

AT&T (NYSE: T) somehow lusted after T-Mobile and offered Deutsche Telekom $39 billion for it. An ounce of intelligent thought would have warned AT&T that the U.S. government would never approve this acquisition, since it would significantly reduce competition and would concentrate far too much market power in AT&T. But once a monopolist, always a monopolist, and the concept of competition still seems to elude AT&T.

Finally, as the government's opposition became crystal clear, AT&T's lust ran out and it announced that the proposed acquisition was dead. But in abandoning the deal, AT&T will pay $4 billion to Deutsche Telekom.

So Deutsche Telecom should develop a new strategy: Seek out suitors and then collect when the deals die! And AT&T shareowners should throw out the management running their company!

A. Michael Noll is Professor Emeritus at the Annenberg School for Communication & Journalism at the University of Southern California. He is a noted expert, author, and historian on the telecommunications industry. His most recent book is Bell Labs Memoirs: Voices of Innovation, available from Amazon.

Suggested Articles

Zayo provides a key element to the project – a backbone fiber network that will link multiple rural markets.

The company is launching its first fiber connectors that are specifically designed to work with 5G small cells.

Veego Software, an Israel-based startup that uses AI to detect and fix problems in connected homes, announced its Home Scoring solution on Thursday.